A set of purple silicone monster-shaped cookie cutters displayed on a light beige background, with a cream drawstring storage bag printed with purple monster illustrations. Text labels include '24 silicone stamps', 'storage bag', 'Lots of monsters cookie cutters', and 'Bonus Cutter!'.
Close-up of the Monster Mix Up kit stamps, showcasing a variety of monster eyes and smile designs.
demonstration of monster themed cookie stamps
Cookie cutter with three monster designs on a beige background
Picture of six stamp and bake monster mixup cookies on a branded parchment paper.
Set of 8 12x16 parchment baking sheets with Halloween-themed designs on a beige background.
A set of purple silicone monster-shaped cookie cutters displayed on a light beige background, with a cream drawstring storage bag printed with purple monster illustrations. Text labels include '24 silicone stamps', 'storage bag', 'Lots of monsters cookie cutters', and 'Bonus Cutter!'.
Close-up of the Monster Mix Up kit stamps, showcasing a variety of monster eyes and smile designs.
demonstration of monster themed cookie stamps
Cookie cutter with three monster designs on a beige background
Picture of six stamp and bake monster mixup cookies on a branded parchment paper.
Set of 8 12x16 parchment baking sheets with Halloween-themed designs on a beige background.

Monster Mix Up Sibling Bundle

$53 $48 Save $5
/
  • FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS $80+
  • In stock, ready to ship
  • Backordered, shipping soon
SELECT ONE:
classic kit
limited edition box
sibling bundle

Our popular Monster Mix Up Stamp & Bake Kit, but with two cookie cutters instead of one – perfect for siblings! Includes:

  • 24 x Monster Face Stamps
  •   2 x Lots Of Monsters Cookie Cutters
  •   8 x Halloween Baking Sheets (Oven-Safe)

What's included

- 24 food-safe silicone cookie stamps
- 2 x Our Lots Of™ Monsters monster-shaped cutter that cuts three cookies at once and is made from durable ABS plastic (BPA-free)
- 8 x Halloween parchment sheets, oven-safe
- Adorable canvas bag for easy storage

Use & Care
Roll out your dough, cut your cookie shapes and then stamp your dough before baking. When you're done, just pop everything in the dishwasher for easy clean up.

Small Parts: Contains small parts. For ages 3+ with adult supervision.

More Creative Baking Fun!

View all
Four house-shaped cookies with embossed designs on a red background, labeled 'Best Seller'.
House shaped cookie stamped with house details before baking
Holiday Village Stamp & Bake Cookie Decorating Kit
$45
Book titled 'The Book of Baking Cheer' with decorative cover on a teal background
Baking kit with cookie cutters, recipe card, and packaging on a white background
Book of Baking Cheer Holiday Baking Set | Limited Edition 2026
$64
Four uniquely designed cookies on a purple background with 'NEW' label.
demonstration of monster themed cookie stamps
Monster Mix Up Stamp & Bake Cookie Decorating Kit
$36
Purple book titled 'The Book of Baking Magic' on a purple background with 'make bake' branding.
Book of Baking Magic Halloween Baking Set | Limited Edition 2026
$68
Two snowman-shaped cookies with red and white decorations on a blue background. NEW
silicone baking cups, stencils, and storage bag with snowman design on a beige background
Cutecakes™ Meet The Snows Bake & Stencil Kit
$34
View all
16 products

Make Baking Magic

Seasonal Baking Pre-Orders
Seasonal Baking
box of Make Bake Holiday Village Cookie Stamp Kit on a pink background surrounded by house cookies and red cookie cutters and cookie stamps
Baking Kits for Kids
Baking Tools for Every Baker
Baking Tools for Every Baker
baking is magic ✨🥣

Creative Bakes Anyone Can Make

Whatever your skill level, I want to help you make baking magic for the ones you love!

Our creative baking tools & naturally vibrant ingredients make it easy to bake from the heart and have fun doing it...

Kristina Schlegel
Founder, pastry chef & mama

Headshot of Make Bake founder Kristina Schlegel wearing a red shirt and a denim apron on a white background