Make Bake Sugar Cookie Mix packaging with colorful heart-shaped cookies on a caramel colored background
Rainbow Heart Sugar Cookies Made With Natural Food Colors and Dye Free Sprinkles
Baked cookies with house shapes on a pink tray, surrounded by cookie cutters and a rolling pin on a wooden surface.
Decorative cookies shaped like Christmas trees on a baking sheet with a decorative paper background.
Colorful bunny-shaped cookies on a white plate with a hand holding a bunny-shaped cookie decorated with natural purple food color and sugars.
Make Bake Sugar Cookie Mix packaging with colorful heart-shaped cookies on a caramel colored background
Rainbow Heart Sugar Cookies Made With Natural Food Colors and Dye Free Sprinkles
Baked cookies with house shapes on a pink tray, surrounded by cookie cutters and a rolling pin on a wooden surface.
Decorative cookies shaped like Christmas trees on a baking sheet with a decorative paper background.
Colorful bunny-shaped cookies on a white plate with a hand holding a bunny-shaped cookie decorated with natural purple food color and sugars.

PRE-ORDER: No Spread Sugar Cookie Mix

$14 $12 Save $2
/
  • SAVE WITH PRE-ORDER PRICING!
  • FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS $100+
  • Ships Sept 4th

Make melt-in-your-mouth sugar cookies with this roll & cut sugar cookie mix. Made with all natural ingredients and a hint of real vanilla. Won't spread in the oven. Homemade sugar cookie making never tasted – or looked – so good 😋

    • Will hold its shape when baking – no spreading!
    • Makes about a dozen cookies, depending on size
    • Just add butter & an egg
    • Works great for Stamp & Bake cookies

Ingredients: Unbleached flour, sugar, real vanilla powder, kosher salt. Produced in a facility that also processes other food allergens.

more halloween baking fun!

Collage style image depiciting all the items in the Book of Magic Baking Set including monster cookie stamps, coffin shaped cupcake liners, monster sticker card, canvas bag for storage, halloween themed parchment paper, sugar cookie recipe, purple and green halloween themed Swedish cloths and color in paper table runner for kids.
Stamp & Bake monster themed sugar cookies where the faces are created with cookie stamps on grid background and purple cookie stamp renderings.
Book of Baking Magic 2026 Limited Edition | Kids' Activity Bundle
$110 $80 Save $30
Collage style image depiciting all the items in the Book of Magic Baking Set including monster cookie stamps, coffin shaped cupcake liners, canvas bag for storage, halloween themed parchment paper, sugar cookie recipe and purple and green halloween themed Swedish cloths.
Stamp & Bake monster themed sugar cookies where the faces are created with cookie stamps on grid background and purple cookie stamp renderings.
Book of Baking Magic 2026 Limited Edition | Baker's Bundle
$88 $68 Save $20
Collage style image of all the items in the creative baking bundle, including the Monster themed Stamp & Bake set, the Cutecakes coffin baking cups and the set of recipe cards.
Stamp & Bake monster themed sugar cookies where the faces are created with cookie stamps on grid background and purple cookie stamp renderings.
Halloween Creative Baking Bundle
$68 $52 Save $16
Picture of six stamp and bake monster mixup cookies on a branded parchment paper.
Stamp & Bake monster themed sugar cookies where the faces are created with cookie stamps on grid background and purple cookie stamp renderings.
Stamp & Bake™ Monster Mix Up Cookie Craft Kit | BUY 2 GET 1 FREE
$36
Set of 6 orange oven-safe silicone baking cups with skeleton design on a white background, featuring the brand 'Cutecakes' by Make Bake. Includes three frosting stencils with skeleton, frankenstein and mummy characters.
Two coffin-shaped silicone baking cups with cake and frosting with skeleton designs frosted on top on a white background.
Cutecakes™ I'm DEAD! Kit
$24 $22 Save $2
Shows three food color packets in purple, green and orange. And shows samples of purple sanding sugar, green sanding sugar and a jimmies sprinkle mix that includes sprinkles in green, purple and orange.
Dye-Free Halloween Sprinkles & Food Color Set
$26 $20 Save $6
Image of a paper table runner with illustrated halloween characters creating a patterned coloring sheet for kids to color in.
Halloween Color-In Paper Table Runner
$14 $12 Save $2
Colorful monster-themed stickers on a purple background. shows 4 monster cards and 2 sticker sheets with monster face parts for decorating the monster careds
Monster Mix Up Reusable Sticker Set
$8 $6 Save $2
View all
View all
19 products
baking is magic ✨🥣

Creative Bakes Anyone Can Make

Whatever your skill level, I want to help you make baking magic for the ones you love!

Our creative baking tools & naturally vibrant ingredients make it easy to bake from the heart and have fun doing it...

Kristina Schlegel
Founder, pastry chef & mama

Headshot of Make Bake founder Kristina Schlegel wearing a red shirt and a denim apron on a white background