All Natural Valentine's Baking Supplies

    Filter

      This Valentine's Day, bake something they'll love with our all-natural baking ingredients, easy-to-use tools and baking kits for kids & adults. Nothing says I ❤️ you more than home baked treats!

      25 products
      Heart-shaped sugar cookies decorated with pink & red icing, surrounded by dye-free food colors and sprinkles on a white background
      Lots Of Hearts Dye-Free Cookie Kit
      $48 $46 Save $2
      A set of four stainless steel cookie cutters in a Valentine's theme, including shapes of a mouth, hearts, a cross, and a rainbow, packaged in a clear plastic box with 'Make Bake' branding.
      Dye-Free Valentine's Cookie Baking Kit
      $56 $54 Save $2
      A set of three dinosaur-shaped cookie cutters in pink, blue, and purple, with the text 'Make Bake' on a clear background.
      Dye-Free Valentine's Dinosaur Cookie Baking Kit
      $56 $54 Save $2
      A set of three cookie cutters in the shapes of a unicorn and a heart with a rainbow background, packaged in a clear plastic box with 'Make Bake' branding.
      Dye-Free Valentine's Unicorn Cookie Baking Kit
      $56 $54 Save $2
      Bottle of Make Bake Valentine's Sprinkle Mix with sprinkles in pink, red and white.
      Dye-Free Valentine's Sprinkle Mix
      $10
      Make Bake Sugar Cookie Mix packaging with colorful heart-shaped cookies on a caramel colored background
      Rainbow Heart Sugar Cookies Made With Natural Food Colors and Dye Free Sprinkles
      No Spread Sugar Cookie Mix
      $12
      Easy Royal Icing Mix Without Meringue Powder for Cookies. Egg Free & Vegan.
      Decorative cookies shaped like Christmas trees on a white plate with green colorant packet on a wooden surface.
      Soft Set Royal Icing Mix
      $10
      Three dye-free Color Kitchen color packs in red, pink, and blue on a white background
      Heart-shaped sugar cookies decorated with pink & red icing, surrounded by dye-free food colors and sprinkles on a white background
      Dye-Free Valentine's Day w/Blue Food Coloring (3 pack)
      $12
      Three packets of Color Kitchen food colorings in pink, purple, and red on a white background.
      Heart-shaped sugar cookies decorated with pink & red icing, surrounded by dye-free food colors and sprinkles on a white background
      Dye-Free Valentine's Day w/Purple Food Coloring (3 pack)
      $12
      Red heart-shaped cookie cutter with multiple heart shapes on a white background
      Heart-shaped cookie cutter being used on a cookie dough with heart-shaped cookies and a pink polka dot napkin in the background.
      Lots Of Hearts Cookie Cutter
      $18
      Set of 7 heart-shaped cookie cutters and storage case on a white background
      Variety of heart-shaped cookies in various sizes with a variety of dye-free colorful icing on a marble surface.
      Heart Cookie Cutter 7 Pcs Set
      $18
      3 oz bottle of Make Bake brand dye-free red sanding sugar with a red label on a background of naturally colored red sugar
      Valentine's Heart Cookies decorated with natural red food coloring and dye free red sanding sugar.
      Dye-Free Ruby Red Sanding Sugar
      $10
      Bottle of Make Bake dye free pink sanding sugar with a red label on a pink sanding sugar background
      Dye-Free Passion Pink Sanding Sugar
      $10
      A bottle of Make Bake natural blue sanding sugar with a red label, placed on a dye free blue sanding sugar background.
      Bunny shaped sugar cookies decorated with natural sanding sugars in various colors
      Dye-Free Sapphire Blue Sanding Sugar
      $10
      3 oz bottle of Make Bake dye-free purple sanding sugar with a red label on a purple sanding sugar background.
      Colorful bunny-shaped cookies on a white plate with a hand holding a bunny-shaped cookie decorated with natural purple food color and sugars.
      Dye-Free Violet Purple Sanding Sugar
      $10
      Two packets of natural red food coloring next to a heart-shaped cookie decorated with the dye-free red frosting.
      White round cake decorated with Christmas trees and snowflakes made with naturally colored frosting on a white plate and topped with cranberries and greenery
      Dye-Free Red Food Coloring (2 pack)
      $8
      Two packets of natural pink food color next to heart-shaped cookies frosted with dye-free pink icing.
      three cupcakes decorated with blue, pink and purple frosting topped with sparklers
      Dye-Free Pink Food Coloring (2 pack)
      $8
      Two packets of blue powdered food color next to heart-shaped cookies decorated with the blue icing.
      snowflake cookies decorated with dye free icing in blue and green
      Dye-Free Blue Food Coloring (2 pack)
      $8
      Heart-shaped cookie with purple frosting and two packets of Color Kitchen purple food color on a white background
      a slice of white birthday cake decorated with dye-free pink and purple frosting, sprinkles and a candle on a white plate
      Dye-Free Purple Food Coloring (2 pack)
      $8
      Set of three heart shaped punch cutters in various sizes on a white background
      Heart Punch Cut Set
      $10
      A set of four stainless steel cookie cutters in a Valentine's theme, including shapes of a mouth, hearts, a cross, and a rainbow, packaged in a clear plastic box with 'Make Bake' branding.
      Nothing But Love Cookie Cutter Set
      $16
      A set of three dinosaur-shaped cookie cutters in pink, blue, and purple, with the text 'Make Bake' on a clear background.
      RAWRsome Dinosaurs Cookie Cutter Set
      $16
      A set of three cookie cutters in the shapes of a unicorn and a heart with a rainbow background, packaged in a clear plastic box with 'Make Bake' branding.
      Unicorn Love is Magic Cookie Cutter Set
      $16
      Better than store bought, this marshmallow frosting is a favorite among kids and adults!
      Marshmallow Buttercream Frosting Mix
      $10
      GF sugar cookie boxed mix made with all natural ingredients. Gluten Free, Dairy Free, Soy Free, Vegan Friendly.
      Sugar Cookie Mix (Gluten Free)
      $12

      Let's Get You Baking

      Creativity

      Thoughtfully designed products to help you get creative with your bakes!

      Our Best Price, Everyday

      Stop chasing sales & shop with confidence. This is how we do pricing.

      Limited Lifetime Guarantee

      We choose premium materials & construction – and we stand behind that.

      baking is magic ✨🥣

      Creative Bakes Anyone Can Make

      Whatever your skill level, I want to help you bake with joy for the ones you love!

      I've crafted quality baking tools and naturally vibrant ingredients to help you bake from the heart – and have fun doing it!

      Kristina Schlegel
      Founder, pastry chef & mama